Beyond “Just Plastic”
Why Design, Not Material, Is the Real Differentiator
Every so often, we hear the misconception that deal toys made from Lucite are “just plastic,” as if the material alone determines the value of the commemorative. The reality is far more nuanced, and far more interesting.
Lucite is a premium, optically clear, cast acrylic with its own history, craftsmanship and performance characteristics. But even that is only part of the story.
The true differentiator in a deal toy is not the material.
It is the design.
Lucite Is a Premium Material, Not a Commodity
Cell cast Lucite is produced through a careful, small batch process. It offers clarity, durability and a visual depth that other materials cannot replicate. It has been used in aerospace, scientific equipment and museum display work long before it entered the world of deal toys.
It is not mass produced.
It is not disposable.
And it is certainly not generic.
When a competitor dismisses everything else as “just plastic,” what they are really doing is overlooking the role of design, craftsmanship and purpose.
Material Alone Does Not Create Meaning
A commemorative made from Lucite can be extraordinary. A commemorative made from crystal can be forgettable. The material does not determine the outcome. The intention behind the design does.
Meaning is created when the designer understands:
• the story of the deal
• the identity of the team
• the significance of the achievement
• the emotion behind the milestone
Materials support that meaning, but they do not define it.
Design Is the True Craft of Deal Toys
Regardless of material, the design is what gives a commemorative its presence. It shapes how the piece sits on a desk, how light interacts with it, how the viewer experiences it and how the story of the deal is expressed.
Design is what differentiates a thoughtful commemorative from a generic one. It determines whether a piece feels intentional or interchangeable, whether it resonates or disappears.
A well designed Lucite block can have more gravitas than a poorly conceived mixed media sculpture. A clean crystal piece can feel more personal than a layered composition that tries to do too much.
Design is the filter that gives meaning its form.
Why Polaris Focuses on Story First, Material Second
When we begin a project, we do not start with the question, “Lucite or crystal?”
We start with:
“What story does this piece need to tell?”
Once that foundation is clear, we choose the materials that best support the story. Sometimes that is Lucite for its optical depth. Sometimes it is crystal for its precision. Sometimes resin or metal provide the detail or structure the concept needs. Sometimes the most powerful choice is simplicity itself.
The material is the medium.
The story is the message.
Design is the bridge between the two.
A Deal Toy Should Never Be Reduced to Its Components
Deals are complex. They require creativity, effort, collaboration and commitment. A commemorative that honors that work deserves more than a dismissive tagline.
The value of a deal toy is not measured by the weight of the crystal or the thickness of the Lucite. It is measured by how faithfully the piece reflects the achievement it represents. That comes from design, intention and understanding.
If you want to see how thoughtful design elevates every material, explore our visual guide:
👉 https://www.polariscustomawards.com/the-power-of-deal-toys
When you are ready to create a commemorative that reflects the real meaning behind your transaction, our team is here to help.
Want to learn more about deal toys? All you need to know is in our Deal Toy Hub
Questions for the Deal Toy Experts? Our FAQ has the answers
Ready to get started? Send us what you have and we’ll map the fastest path